The Reality Of Feminism In Pakistan- 3 Things To Know And Ponder

‘Feminism’ over the years has become a pseudo-curse word in Pakistani society. The minute a woman wants her basic human rights, the same rights she sees men of her own country enjoy, she is vehemently labeled a feminist. The hatred and disgust with which the word is hurled at her, is enough to silence a good number of such upstarts. But the fact of the matter is, it’s not a curse word. In fact, as far as Feminism in Pakistani society is concerned, there are a few things all of us Pakistani men and women need to know;
1. The Definition:
Feminism is the radical notion that women are people. This radical notion is NOT the brainchild of the west, it is the brainchild of Islam. When Islam opposed female infanticide, when the preaching of Islam was initially funded by the business profits of a woman (Hazrta Khadija RA, the first wife of the Holy Prophet SAW), when Islam defended the right of women in inheritance, when Islam made men responsible for the women they married or had/wanted to have carnal relations with, when Islam made men own the children they sired, when Islam curtailed polygamy, etc, etc it was basically treating women like humans, like people. Bottom line is, people (men and women) who throw the word ‘feminism’ in a woman’s face to the affect of labeling her a kaafir, are ignorant, simply ignorant. I feel sorry for the women who have to put up with them.
2. The West Didn’t Export It To Us:
Contrary to popular belief, the so-called ‘feminist movement’ is not a hand-me-down dress from the west. It is not a ‘yahoodiyoon ki saazish’. It is the weakness of our own society. It is the weakness or lack of faith on our part. There is a reason why armies used to build strong forts in the old days, you can’t enter a city if it is surrounded by unbreakable walls. Our society gives women no such walls. For example;

1. If a guy earns for his family, he is a good son, a good father, a good husband, a good brother. All the praises in the world for him from his parents, siblings, spouse and kids.
2. If a woman bears and brings up children well, that’s her job. She is supposed to do it. Every penny that is spent on her, even the cost of delivering the child is counted and recorded for future reference. In all fairness, this counting is not just the men’s doing, women are equally involved. No body praises her. I mean they will post on blogs and write to newspapers volumes worth of articles about the status of women in Islam and how they respect their women, but then can someone please provide a logical explanation as to why these well-loved and well-respected Paksitani women who are your blood sisters so fed-up of being oppressed. They’re stupid? Your sisters are stupid? Really? Doesn’t say much about you does it?

3. Women Are As Much Responsible For The Uprise As The Men:

It’s easy to think men are solely responsible for the injustice dealt to women, they seem like an obvious target. But the fact is, within the home, when a mother decides to favor her son over her daughter, she is just as bad as the father who favors the sons over the daughter. I remember a Pakistan Studies class in which a teacher narrated that there are families where the sisters will constantly belittle their brothers’ wives so they can eventually control their brothers’ income. Granted that those are some seriously stupid brothers, but the women are guilty of injustice as well. A mother has the power to raise her children with the finest values, so much so that Hazrat Ali RA advised men ‘Don’t look for a wife for yourselves, look for a mother for your children’. And when, knowledgeable of this power, abuse it, it is simply despicable. No woman from the west ever came and taught the Pakistani women that it was the sisters’ JOB to eat only after her brother had eaten, this is our own invention. What’s worse is, when these sisters grow up, they take these very same ‘values’ and put them into bringing up their own children.

A Few Muslim Practices:

Here are a few Islamic Rights conferred to women, as a sample of how our “you feminist” shouting meat-heads wouldn’t survive day if Shariat was ever implemented in this country;

1. In Islam a woman is not bound to adopt her husband’s name or her husband’s family name. She is known by her father’s name and, like all humans, will be raised on the Day of Judgement by her father’s name, not her husbands. Nuff said. (Update: Sahih Hadith mentions that people will be raised on the Day of Judgment by their father’s name.)

2. In Islam, when you bring something to eat home, like customarily fathers bring fruits home, the first fruit is to be offered to the daughters, starting with the youngest.

3. A woman’s property, inherited from her father, or built through business, or given to her as her own possession via gift, is her property. Her husband/father/brother/son has no claim to it in her life. If she gives part or all of it to them, that is charity on her part and she will be rewarded, but it is not their right.

The list is pretty long, in fact books have been written over this subject. Of course, all this being said, the fact that there is plenty wrong and outright vulgar going on in the name feminism can’t be denied. But just as undefended borders are no borders at all, similarly a society eons away from its own value system and in an identity crisis is easy prey. We shouldn’t blame the vultures, we should blame ourselves for feeding them.

What we need as Muslim Pakistanis (men and women alike), is to give our mothers, daughters, sisters and wives the confidence that our religion prescribes, without waiting for them to ask for it, or leaving them no choice but to ask for what is rightly theirs. Only then would there be no semblance of this so-called feminism. We women would simply give a resounding shut-up call to anyone who told us we’re oppressed.

About momina wahab

a curious girl...always asking questions and finally starting to make some sense out of life ...
This entry was posted in May, 2011 and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to The Reality Of Feminism In Pakistan- 3 Things To Know And Ponder

  1. you are very -ve thinking woman… why women always moans?

  2. momina wahab says:

    Facts are facts, stating them is not moaning.

    I could also ask you why men have no compassion for the women in their lives, but then that would be assuming you represent all the men in the world (or even Pakistan). So I’ll rephrase, how come YOU have so little compassion for your fellow Muslim women? Why do you think they have no right to justice and a blog post that highlights injustices done to them is ‘moaning’?

  3. KISSA says:

    There were better words he could use instead of using his “Family Term”. I totally agree with you Momina.

  4. Logical Dude says:

    Dear Friends, I am very interested in women’s rights. Whenever a young female in our family is getting married I am thinking in my own head will she be treated well by her husband and susral in the long term or not. How to recognize that the tretment she is receiving is proper and respectful. If I could I would have a chat with them. It is usually not possible. I authored a “woman’s bill of rights” in the context of Pakistani culture. I would like a Pakistani-muslim femanist to review it and help me improve it. If you can help please write back.

    • momina wahab says:

      Hi, I appreciate your effort. I would like to help, but I am not a lawyer. Do you plan on taking the bill to NA? or publishing it in newspapers for gaining traction for the plight of Pakistani Women?

      Take care.

      • Syed Kamal says:

        It would be well and proper to get legislation on the books to deal with abuse of women’s rights in our society. But I think the first step is to create awareness in the minds of victims of their rights, what these rights are based on and what options may be available to her.
        Even educated and enlightened females are afraid to assert their rights. We need to start a conversation about identifying abuse in relationships of all kinds. Conversation has to be in the context Pakistani/Muslim culture.

  5. momina wahab says:

    @Syed Kamal: You have a point.

  6. Rehan khalid says:

    Very good article regarding feminism in pakistan and islamic point of view.

  7. Mahmood Ahmad Bhatti says:

    one reason is fact is fact, and this is a ground reality, you are right in one aspect, but keep in mind u r living in Pakistan an Islamic state, you are very negative mind woman and also misguide other women.

  8. Black n Blue says:

    Wonderful article, best thing it puts responsibility on both men & women.

    ‘ If a woman bears and brings up children well ‘

    This point didn’t make any sense, its more like you were super angry when you wrote it. I know many women who work hard while their husbands eat. Such men are barely respected in public as well as their own circles.
    As far as counting the money spent & documenting for future reference is concerned, it is the best encounter against the trade mark phrase ‘aap nai kiya hi kiya hai?’. And believe it or not, this is very common.

    For your information, no Hadith states that the people will be raised by the names of their mothers. Sahih Hadith say that everyone would be raised by the name of their fathers.

    • momina wahab says:

      Thank you for the Hadith correction. You’re right. JizakAllah. The point about women bearing and raising children was that when women do their job, everyone says ‘you’re doing your job’ (no praises) When men go out and earn, which is their job, everyone praises them. I find this unfair and discouraging.

  9. asalam o alaikum,momina i cant explain the joy i feel on finally reading a woman who isnt a product or victim of this society and its bullshit but has a mind of her own and voices her opinions. i would love to discuss some things over with you via email if possible. kindly do answer.

Leave a comment